The Science Fiction Review Books Dune Messiah by Frank Herbert

Dune Messiah by Frank Herbert

Dune Messiah Book Cover

Frank Herbert continues his epic saga with Dune Messiah. Paul “Muad’Dib” Atreides has been Emperor for 12 years following the ending of the first novel when he took over. He has become a god figure, messiah, to the Fremen, which have ravaged the galaxy spreading their religion to countless worlds. Paul has not been able to prevent the jihad, but has been able to control it in a way.

I never wanted to be a god, he thought. I wanted only to disappear like a jewel of trace dew caught in the morning. I wanted to escape the angles and the damned—alone … as though by an oversight.

Princess Irulan continues to compile her histories, denied the physical attention of Paul. Chani and Paul have tried to conceive and heir, but have yet to be successful. It turns out that Irulan has been slipping a contraceptive into Chani’s food, hoping that Paul will give up and produce an heir with herself.

There is a conspiracy involving the Reverend Mother Gaius Helen Mohiam, Princess Irulan, a Tleilaxu Face Dancer of the Bene Tleilax (which has the ability to perfectly mimic the appearance, voice, and demeanor of others) named Scytale, and a guild navigator named Edric. They hope to destroy Paul and take back control of Dune and the spice trade. The reason they can conspire against Paul is that he cannot foresee events which involve guild navigators. They create a type of interference which Paul cannot penetrate with his skills as the kwisatz haderach.

An interesting trait of Scytale, as with all Tleilaxu, is that he is willing to help destroy Paul, but only if there is a chance of escape. The tool which they will use to destroy Paul is a ghola (essentially an advanced clone), grown from the remains of Duncan Idaho. This is a being with the mannerisms, skills, and demeanor of the old Duncan, but without his memories. The man, called Hayt, is presented as a gift to Paul by Edric. Paul could refuse the gift, but that would be very poor form in the realm of politics.

Paul accepts Hayt, with reservation, perceiving some sort of trickery. He asks Hayt if he is meant to destroy Paul, which he confirms. Paul, however, keeps Hayt by his side. This reminds me of the saying, “Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer.” Although Hayt knows that he is meant to destroy Paul, he’s unaware of the specific circumstances.

Hayt ends up being one of my favorite characters in this book. Those he interacts with are constantly comparing him to the original Duncan Idaho, prompting Hayt to question his own existence and purpose. One significant difference between Hayt and Duncan is that Hayt has been trained as a mentat and in Zensunni philosophy. Hayt/Duncan plays a pivotal role, constantly trying to ascertain how he will be used to destroy Paul. He truly has no desire to hurt Paul, and begs to be sent away.

Paul knows that he must pay a high price to end the jihad, as seen through one of his prescient visions. Throughout the novel Paul struggles with deciding whether or not he is willing to pay that price. The specific price is known to Paul, but not revealed to the reader. What is most interesting is how Frank Herbert unveils the scope of Paul’s power. Visions of the future and past converge, branching out into countless possibilities. Paul’s goal is to force events to follow the one path which will end the jihad.

Little stumbles here and there suggest that Paul isn’t as omnipotent as he hopes to be. Subtle differences pop up not quite matching his visions, then suddenly it seems that he locks on to the future he was searching for. Paul is a reluctant messiah, but the powers that he exhibits after this revelation only reinforce his god-like status with the Fremen.

From then on we see Paul bravely following the path he has foreseen to his own destruction. There are plenty of twists and turns, many of which caught me by surprise. Technology seems to be much more prevalent in this book, compared to the first one. The complex interactions are still there, with the welcome addition of the interesting Bene Tleilax. The pacing is much more consistent, with the entire events of the novel taking place at one after another, rather than over three distinct sections as in the first novel. Overall, I was very pleased with this sequel, and if anything, like it better than the original.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please prove you are a human * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Post

Pebble in the Sky by Isaac AsimovPebble in the Sky by Isaac Asimov

Pebble in the Sky book cover

The book opens up in 1949 on the day of a mysterious accident at Chicago’s Institute of Nuclear Research. Joseph Schwartz, while walking around on the other side of Chicago is somehow caught in an expanding beam of energy that transports him into an unfamiliar place. Actually, he has not traveled to another place but another time. Earth’s land is largely covered in radioactive soil, so that it can only support 20 million people. The result of this is the common practice of terminating anyone that cannot work or when they reach the age of sixty as a form of strict population control. Most people don’t resent this practice but rather look at as a way for making room for the young. (more…)

Cobra by Timothy ZahnCobra by Timothy Zahn

Book Cover

I recently started reading the Cobra Trilogy by Timothy Zahn. Cobra, the first book in the series, starts off just after the beginning of the Troft war with the Dominion of Man. At the beginning of the novel, the Trofts have already conquered a two key worlds in the outer systems. The military, in a desperate move, created the Cobra program to train an elite force of enhanced soldiers. One of the first things that came to mind when I came across this series was Starship Troopers, the BOOK, not the movie. I immensely enjoyed the first few chapters of Starship Troopers with the cap troopers in the Mobile Infantry. The main difference is that instead of troopers inside of huge external mech hardware, the Cobras’ enhancements are essentially hidden, yet very deadly. On the outside they look like a normal human, which is one of their advantages.
(more…)

Isaac Asimov’s Caliban by Roger MacBride AllenIsaac Asimov’s Caliban by Roger MacBride Allen

Caliban book cover

I was glad to break into a new series after reading sixteen books with Derec and Ariel as main characters. Roger MacBride Allen brings the robot Caliban to life from “infancy” from when he is first powered up. Caliban awakens with his arm half raised to see the body of a woman laying on the floor, which later turns out to be his creator Fredda Leving. If Caliban was a normal robot he would have sent for help immediately, but unfortunately he was created lacking the infamous Three Laws of Robotics. Instead, Caliban investigates the scene briefly and then ventures out to explore this new unfamiliar world. (more…)